Benefits:
401(k) matching
Bonus based on performance
Company parties
Competitive salary
Flexible schedule
Paid time off
Vision insurance
Want to build your own business one day? We’ll show you how.
At Cisneros Agency, we're not looking for someone who just wants another sales job. We're looking for someone who wants to develop a career. You'll learn how to prospect, uncover client needs, build relationships, sell multiple lines of insurance, develop referral sources, and grow a book of business.
For the right person, this role can also create a path toward leadership or eventually owning an insurance agency.
Our agency operates around four core values: Commitment, Dependability, Integrity, and Achievement. We believe in taking care of clients, doing what we say we're going to do, continually improving, and helping each other win.
As one of the top 2% of agency teams in the nation with American Family Insurance for over a decade, we’re looking for our next A-player to join our mission and build a rewarding career in insurance sales with a clear path to agency ownership.
What You'll Do
Prospect for new business Build a consistent sales pipeline through outbound calls, referrals, centers of influence, community relationships, existing clients, and agency marketing campaigns.
Conduct insurance consultations Learn about each client's situation, identify gaps in coverage, recommend appropriate solutions, and guide prospects through the buying process using our proven Agency Relationship Process.
Build multi-policy relationships Look beyond the initial sale. Identify opportunities to help clients with auto, home, life, umbrella, commercial, and other insurance needs.
Develop referral relationships Build relationships with clients, lenders, local businesses, community partners, and other centers of influence who can become long-term referral sources.
Participate in community marketing Work alongside agency leadership at networking, community, and marketing events to create new opportunities for the agency.
Train and improve Participate in ongoing sales coaching, call reviews, role-playing, and skill development. We expect you to accept feedback, apply it, and continually improve.
Collaborate with the team Work closely with sales and service team members to deliver a strong client experience and help the agency reach shared goals.
What We're Looking For
We care more about drive, character, communication skills, and coachability than having years of insurance experience.
1-2 years of experience in sales, customer service, hospitality, business development, or another client-facing role
Comfortable communicating with people by phone, email, video, and in person
Willing to prospect and initiate conversations with people you don't already know
Strong listening skills and curiosity about clients' needs
Competitive and goal-oriented, while still putting the client's interests first
Coachable and willing to implement feedback
Organized and able to consistently follow a sales process
Self-motivated and able to work without constant supervision
Bilingual Spanish/English preferred
Licensing & Training
Already licensed? Great.
Not licensed yet? We'll help you get there.
The agency will provide paid training time for insurance licensing and cover one attempt at the required licensing exams. You'll also receive ongoing sales training, coaching, and development after you're licensed.
Compensation & Benefits:
Compensation: $21.63 - $26.44/hour base pay + uncapped commissions after a 90-day training period.
Top-Tier Earning potential: On-target earnings for top performers are $65,000 - $100,000+.
100% employer-paid health, dental, and vision for employee
Traditional 401k with 3% company match
Unlimited PTO + Volunteer Time Off
Flexible work schedule and paid training.
Where This Role Can Lead
Success in this position can open opportunities for:
Sales Specialist → Senior Sales/Leadership → Agency Ownership or Department Leadership
We're willing to invest in someone who wants to learn the business, become excellent at sales, take on greater responsibility, and build something meaningful over time.
Ready to Build Your Future?
If you're looking for a comfortable job where leads simply show up and you wait for the phone to ring, this probably isn't the right fit.
But if you enjoy meeting people, building relationships, pursuing opportunities, learning how a business grows, and being rewarded for the results you create, we'd like to meet you.
Apply today and tell us what you're hoping to build over the next five years.
Flexible work from home options available.
This position is an Agency Team Member working for the Agency Owner and is not an employee of American Family Insurance.